A Revolutionary Paleoindicator: Lepidoptera Scales
Moth scales, preserved in the mud of a coniferous forest lake, have been used to identify outbreaks of these insects over the past 10,000 years. This groundbreaking new technique, reported in the open-access journal Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution, can tell us more about the frequency and intensity of past and future insect epidemics, their impact on the forest environment and how they are linked to climate change.
Photo 1: Lepidoptera wing scales. Thousands of scales cover the moth body and wings like shingles on a roof, arranged in rows and anchored in a socket. Credit: Emy Tremblay. Edition: Miguel Montoro Girona. Method: Optical microscope from Université de Québec à Chicoutimi (Hubert Morin) x100. Details: Scale size = 50µm; original color has been modified.
Photo 2: The diversity in shapes and colors make scales a potential proxy to identify Lepidoptera species. Examples of scale morphotypes of spruce budworm. Credit: Emy Tremblay. Edition: Miguel Montoro Girona. Method: Optical microscope from microscope from Université de Québec à Chicoutimi (Hubert Morin). Details: Scale size = 50 µm.
“This is an exciting discovery, which will greatly increase our knowledge of prehistoric forest ecosystems,” says Dr. Miguel Montoro Girona, lead author of this paper, based at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Umeå, Sweden. “It is comparable to the fossil pollen and charcoal markers in sediments, which revolutionized prehistoric research to provide information on plants, climate and forest fires going back thousands of years. Our new method can be applied to many ecosystems where moths and butterflies have a marked influence on the landscape.”
Moths are one of the most widespread and recognizable insects in the world. In the boreal forests of North America, which are mainly comprised of coniferous, evergreen trees, the larva of one moth species — the Spruce Budworm — can periodically cause severe and widespread damage. This leads to millions of dollars of lost revenue to the forest-based economy.
It was during a routine observation of one of these outbreaks that the researchers had a ‘eureka’ moment.
Photo 3: Boreal forests under insect outbreak period. North-Shore, Quebec- Canada, 2017. Credit: Miguel Montoro Girona.
“Together with an insect specialist, we recently identified a ‘strange’ structure in a colleague’s lake-water sample, which turned out to be a scale from a moth wing,” says Dr. Hubert Morin, co-author, based at the Québec University, Canada. “Afterwards, during a Spruce Budworm outbreak, I noticed the lakes were covered in dead moths. Knowing they are made from a material that is likely to be well-preserved in the sediments of lakes, I realized they had the potential to provide information about these swarms going back thousands of years.”
Photo 5 and 6: Dead moths of spruce budworm (Choristoneura fumiferana – SBW) floating on the surface of a boreal lake during the insect outbreak period. North of Lake Saint-Jean, Quebec- Canada, 2017. Credit: Hubert Morin
This hunch turned out to be true. Taking a 5-meter-long core of sediment from a forest lake near Québec, which represented 10,000 years’ worth of sediment deposit, the researchers at the Québec University spent five years perfecting their method of extracting, examining and counting moth scales under the microscope from each sediment layer.
“Our analysis revealed peaks of moth scales that corresponded to known periods of insect outbreak. This means we can work out when these epidemics occurred before records began,” says Dr. Lionel Navarro, based at the Québec University, who spent a lot of time in the laboratory processing these samples. “This new method will be of enormous help to future research in areas as wide as ecology and evolution, biodiversity conservation, climate change and forestry.”
Photo 7: The diversity in shapes and colors make scales a potential proxy to identify Lepidoptera species. Examples of scale morphotypes of spruce budworm. Credit: Lionel Navarro. Edition: Miguel Montoro Girona. Method: Optical microscope from microscope from Université de Québec à Chicoutimi (Hubert Morin). Details: Scale size = 50 µm.
The authors explain, “Using the Spruce Budworm as an example, moths and butterflies can be one of the most important natural disturbances, changing the forest structure and species composition, with strong economic implications to forestry and agriculture. They are an ‘umbrella species’ — the second most diverse animal group in the world — so improving our understanding of these creatures will in turn provide a lot of information about other species and the state of the ecosystem they are in.”
They continue, “Currently, climate change is one of the biggest challenges of our planet. Understanding our past ecosystems is essential to predicting the future. Based on climate-change predictions, insect outbreaks will be more frequent, with higher severity. Our new technique can help us understand how moths and butterflies react to different climatic scenarios and environmental changes, so we can predict their response to climate change, as well as their vulnerability and extinction risk.”
Original article: A Secret Hidden in the Sediments: Lepidoptera Scales
Corresponding author: Dr. Miguel Montoro Girona